英文互译镜像站

Canada and the 2026 Iran war

Last updated

The Canadian government has officially abstained from joining in the 2026 U.S.-led Israel war in Iran. [1] [2] Although Canada has previously been involved in joint operations with the U.S. in regards to Iran, most notably the 1979/80 Canadian Caper, [3] Canada has long been reluctant to participate in military interventions that are lacking UN Security Council approval. [4] The Canadian government has prioritized diplomatic solutions to end the international crisis, [5] a strategy supported by the Canadian public that is weary of deploying Canadian peacekeepers or being directly involved in any military offensives. [6] [7] [8]

Contents

Domestically there have been debates whether Canada would be willing to help its NATO allies in defence of Gulf states, [9] or assist with the stabilization of the strait of Hormuz. [10] Questions have arisen regarding the involvement of Canadian exchange officers in planning and intelligence, [11] and why the presence of Canadian soldiers at sites attacked by Iran was not disclosed to the public. [12]

Diplomatic relations between Canada and Iran are basically non existent, [13] with a lack of formal diplomatic ties since 2012. [14] Canada has placed sanctions on Iran since 2010, [15] and has pursued legal action against Iran through the International Court of Justice regarding the 2020 downing of Flight PS752. [16]

Foreign relations context

Americans grateful for Canadian aid in sheltering and rescuing American diplomats during the Iran hostage crisis called the "Canadian Caper", 1980. ThanksCanada.JPG
Americans grateful for Canadian aid in sheltering and rescuing American diplomats during the Iran hostage crisis called the "Canadian Caper", 1980.

Canada and the United States have a long and complex relationship; [17] historically close allies, they co-operate regularly on military campaigns and intelligent exchange; [18] the Canadian Caper was a covert joint operation which Canadian diplomats sheltered and evacuated six American diplomats who had escaped the initial seizure of the U.S. Embassy in Tehran during the Iran hostage crisis. [19] This event significantly strained Canadian-Iranian relations while highlighting the close alliance between Canada and the U.S. [3] Notwithstanding, Canada has long been reluctant to participate in U.S.-led military operations that are not sanctioned by the United Nations, [4] [20] such as the Vietnam War or the 2003 Invasion of Iraq. [4] [20]

Diplomatic relations between the United States and Canada have recently been strained since a trade war involving the United States began on 1 February 2025, when U.S. president Donald Trump signed orders imposing tariffs on goods entering the United States, alongside rhetoric suggesting the annexation of Canada. [21]

Canada has not had a formal diplomatic presence in Iran since 2012, with the Canadian government stating in 2026 that restoration of ties would require a change in the Iranian regime. [22] Canada has imposed significant, autonomous sanctions on Iran for over 15 years, with the first "Made-in-Canada" sanctions established in July 2010, and the newest sanctions implemented in early 2026. [15]

On 8 January 2020, a Boeing 737-800 was shot down by the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) shortly after take off killing all 176 occupants on board, including 57 Canadians. [23] Canada has sought legal action against Iran through the International Court of Justice "in pursuit of accountability and full reparation". [16] In June 2024, Canada officially designated the IRGC as a terrorist organization under the Canadian Criminal Code. [24]

In March 2026, Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney and Foreign Affairs Minister Anita Anand stated Canada supports efforts preventing Iran from obtaining nuclear weapons but expressed regret over certain U.S.-strikes that appeared inconsistent with international law. [25]

Official position

Gen. Jennie Carignan, Chief of the Defence Staff, Canadian Armed Forces, at the Pentagon, October 2024 General CQ Brown, Jr. meets with General Jennie Carignan, Chief of the Defence Staff, Canadian Armed Forces, at the Pentagon, USA on 22 October 2024.jpg
Gen. Jennie Carignan, Chief of the Defence Staff, Canadian Armed Forces, at the Pentagon, October 2024

On 3 March 2026, during a visit to Australia, Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney described the war as a "failure of the international order" and claimed that the United States had not consulted its allies before striking Iran. [26] The following day, Carney stated that Canada would not rule out military involvement in the 2026 Iran war and that Canada "will stand by our allies, when it makes sense." [27] This was followed by, Chief of the Defence Staff General Jennie Carignan stating that Canada "may be called on to help defend Persian Gulf states from Iran's strikes" and that the situation in the gulf states is "quite dire and dangerous." [28]

On 9 March 2026, Canadian defence minister David McGuinty stated that Canada "will not be participating" in the Iran war despite Mark Carney's prior comments about not ruling out military involvement. [29] Carney stated the following day that Canada "is not participating in the United States and Israeli offensive and will never participate in it." [30]

On 19 March 2026, Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney stated that Canada is willing "to contribute to efforts to reopen the Strait of Hormuz." [31] On that same day, Canadian defence minister David McGuinty said that Canada is "considering" helping Iran's neighbours defend themselves if they request assistance from NATO. [32]

Criticisms

Conservative party leader Pierre Poilievre speaking at a protest marking 1,000 days since the Iranian Revolutionary Guards shot down UIA Flight 752, October 2022 Pierre Poilievre at Iran protest.jpg
Conservative party leader Pierre Poilievre speaking at a protest marking 1,000 days since the Iranian Revolutionary Guards shot down UIA Flight 752, October 2022

The official Canadian position on the Iran war has been met with several criticisms due to conflicting statements during the initial phases of the military action. [34] Conservative foreign affairs critic Michael Chong accused Carney of contradicting himself and holding an "utterly incoherent position on Iran over the past few days." [35] Conservative party leader Pierre Poilievre accused Carney of "confusing our allies and dividing Canadians" by repeatedly shifting positions on the strikes. Poilievre also added, "Now he has gone into hiding, having failed to speak a single word in tonight's debate. In this time of crisis, Canadians deserve to know where the prime minister stands." [36]

NDP foreign affairs critic Alexandre Boulerice stated that the NDP was disappointed with the Prime Minister's response to the war. [37] Former Canadian foreign affairs minister Lloyd Axworthy described the Canadian government's official response to the Iran war as "very confusing." [38]

Public opinion

An Ipsos poll for Global News released in March 2026, reveals that 61% of Canadians disapprove of the military strike against Iran, with 42% strongly against it. Only 23% approve, and 16% are unsure. Concerns about Canada's possible involvement in the war are significant, with 66% worried about the safety of Canadian soldiers. 41%, of Canadians believe the conflict will not end soon with only 32% thinking it will be resolved in a couple of months. The survey also revealed that Canadians generally prefer solving the Iran conflict through diplomatic discussions with aid rather than using military force. There is only negligible support for sending Canadian troops to maintain peace or for military help to the U.S. [6]

A Leger poll also released in March 2026, indicates approximately 6 out of 10 Canadians (58%) do not agree with the bombing of Iran by the U.S. and Israel. 70% of Canadians believe Canada should stay neutral and not take sides in the conflict. Only 25% think Canada should help the U.S. and Israel with their attacks on Iran. 59% of Canadians would agree to send ground troops to help protect a NATO country if Iran attacked them. Support goes down to 54% for defending oil refineries and shipping, and drops to 39% for being part of a group trying to change the government in Iran. [7]

Involvement

Planning and intelligence

The Department of National Defence has denied Canadian involvement in assisting with air strikes that several former military officials and journalists have alleged. [39] According to retired Major-General Denis Thompson, it was likely that Canadian soldiers of the Combined Aerospace Operations Centre of the 1 Canadian Air Division gave intelligence support for the strikes on Iran and would have been "directly involved in targeting". [40] On the topic of potential Canadian involvement, former Canadian foreign affairs minister Lloyd Axworthy wrote, "You cannot embed Canadian officers in U.S. war-fighting headquarters, plug Canadian intelligence into targeting processes, then wash your hands when missiles fly. If Canadian personnel helped plan, analyze or enable an operation, Canada is implicated — whether or not a Canadian finger was on the trigger." [41]

Presence of Canadian soldiers at sites attacked by Iran

An aerial view of "Log Town" at Al Udeid Air Base in 2004 Al Udeid Air Base.jpg
An aerial view of "Log Town" at Al Udeid Air Base in 2004

According to a CBC News report citing the Canadian Department of National Defence's website, members of the Combined Aerospace Operations Centre of the 1 Canadian Air Division were present at the Al Udeid Air Base in Qatar the time of the Iranian attack as were Canadian soldiers working at the U.S. Fifth Fleet headquarters in Bahrain when Iran stuck the headquarters. [42] On 3 March 2026, Canadian Defence Minister David McGuinty confirmed Canadian military presence in the Middle East and confirmed that they had not suffered any casualties. McGuinty also stated that the Canadian Armed Forces will "assess any potential impacts on CAF personnel in the region." [43] Later that day, an Iranian missile struck Al Udeid Air Base but did not cause any casualties. [44] On 12 March 2026, it was revealed that the Camp Canada military base located within the Ali Al Salem Air Base in Kuwait was struck by Iranian missiles on 2 March 2026. During the attack, Canadian soldiers took shelter inside bunkers and suffered no casualties. Satellite images showed that Canadian bunkers had been damaged during the attack. [45] After the news of strikes was made public, the Canadian government faced criticism for not being transparent about the attack. [46]

See also

References

  1. The Canadian Press (11 March 2026). "Canada will 'never participate' in Iran offensive, Carney says". CTVNews. Retrieved 29 March 2026.
  2. Fraser, Suzan (17 March 2026). "Canada was not consulted on Iran war and won't join offensive action, minister says". The Washington Post. Retrieved 13 April 2026.
  3. 1 2 Hillmer, Norman (18 October 2013). "Ken Taylor and the "Canadian Caper"". The Canadian Encyclopedia. Retrieved 30 March 2026.
  4. 1 2 3 Massie, Justin (30 April 2019). "Why Canada Goes to War: Explaining Combat Participation in US-led Coalitions". Canadian Journal of Political Science. 52 (3). Cambridge University Press (CUP): 575–594. doi:10.1017/s0008423919000040.
  5. Press, Canadian (2 March 2026). "Canada urges diplomatic solution in Iran, won't say if it views strikes as illegal". TorontoToday.ca. Retrieved 1 April 2026.
  6. 1 2 Bricker, Darrell (13 March 2026). "Majority of Canadians Disapprove of US Military Strike Against Iran - The public favours diplomatic solutions and humanitarian aid over military involvement in addressing the crisis in Iran". Ipsos. Retrieved 1 April 2026.
  7. 1 2 Malboeuf, Daphnée (18 March 2026). "Iran War: Most Canadians Want Neutrality, Leger Poll Finds". Leger. Retrieved 1 April 2026.
  8. Reid, Angus (17 March 2026). "Amid widening Middle East war, Canadians reject military role in Iran by seven-to-one margin". Angus Reid Institute. Retrieved 2 April 2026.
  9. Tunney, Catharine (5 March 2026). "Canada could be called on to help defend Gulf states, says top military commander". CBC. Retrieved 29 March 2026.
  10. Fallico, Adriana; Boynton, Sean (19 March 2026). "Canada and allies say they could 'contribute' efforts on Strait of Hormuz". Global News. Retrieved 29 March 2026.
  11. Brewster, Murray (1 March 2026). "Did Canadian exchange officers participate in U.S. Iran strike planning? DND says no, but questions linger". CBC. Retrieved 29 March 2026.
  12. Ha, Stephanie (13 March 2026). "Ottawa questioned why Iranian strike on military hub with Canadian forces was not made public". CTVNews. Retrieved 1 April 2026.
  13. Rana, Uday (15 January 2026). "Why Canada doesn't have diplomatic relations with Iran anymore". Global News. Retrieved 1 April 2026.
  14. Global Affairs Canada (7 September 2012). "Canada Closes Embassy in Iran, Expels Iranian Diplomats from Canada". Canada.ca. Retrieved 1 April 2026.
  15. 1 2 "Canadian Sanctions Related to Iran". GAC. 19 October 2015. Retrieved 29 March 2026.
  16. 1 2 "Canada's response to Ukraine International Airlines Flight 752 tragedy". GAC. 29 May 2017. Retrieved 1 April 2026.
  17. Carment, D.; Sands, C. (2019). Canada–US Relations: Sovereignty or Shared Institutions?. Canada and International Affairs. Springer International Publishing. pp. 3–10. ISBN   978-3-0300-5036-8.
  18. "Rescue of the "Canadian Six"–A Classic Case of Deception". CIA. 4 November 1979. Retrieved 30 March 2026.
  19. 1 2 Mingst, K.; Karns, M.P. (2019). The United Nations In The Post-cold War Era, Second Edition. Taylor & Francis. p. 63. ISBN   978-1-000-30674-3.
  20. Grantham-Philips, Wyatte (12 March 2025). "Trump has imposed sweeping tariffs. Here's a timeline of how we got here". CBC. Retrieved 13 March 2025.
  21. The Canadian Press (16 February 2026). "Anand says 'regime change' in Iran would be required for restarting diplomatic ties". CTVNews. Retrieved 29 March 2026.
  22. The Canadian Press (11 January 2020). "'Our profound regrets': Iran state TV says Ukrainian jet was 'unintentionally' shot down". National Post. Retrieved 30 March 2026.
  23. Burke, Ashley; Woods, Michael (19 June 2024). "Canada listing Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps as terrorist group after years of pressure". CBC. Retrieved 29 March 2026.
  24. Boynton, Sean (3 March 2026). "Carney reaffirms Canada's support for strikes on Iran 'with regret'". Global News. Retrieved 29 March 2026.
  25. "Canada PM Carney says Iran conflict a failure of the international order". Reuters. 4 March 2026. Retrieved 6 March 2026.
  26. "Canada won't rule out military participation in Middle East conflict: PM Carney". CTV News. 4 March 2026. Retrieved 6 March 2026.
  27. "Canada could be called on to help defend Gulf states, says top military commander". CBC News. 5 March 2026. Retrieved 6 March 2026.
  28. "Canada 'will not be participating' in Iran war, defence minister says". Global News. 9 March 2026. Retrieved 11 March 2026.
  29. "Canada will 'never participate' in Iran offensive, Carney says". CTV News. 10 March 2026. Retrieved 11 March 2026.
  30. "Ottawa outlines criteria for helping Gulf nations hit by Iran war". CTV News. 20 March 2026. Retrieved 25 March 2026. On Thursday, Prime Minister Mark Carney endorsed a statement by allies — after it was released — expressing a willingness to contribute to efforts to reopen the Strait of Hormuz, which Iran has blockaded.
  31. "Ottawa outlines criteria for helping Gulf nations hit by Iran war". CTV News. 20 March 2026. Retrieved 25 March 2026. Defence Minister David McGuinty added that Canada is "considering" helping Iran's neighbours defend themselves if they seek assistance from the NATO alliance.
  32. Robertson, Dylan (4 October 2022). "Flight PS752 families want Ottawa to get tougher on Iran". CTV. BellMedia. Archived from the original on 14 August 2024. Retrieved 29 December 2024.
  33. Narayan, Shankar (16 March 2026). "Carney's Hesitation on Iran Is Smart Strategy". Macleans.ca (in French). Retrieved 29 March 2026.
  34. "Canada could be called on to help defend Gulf states, says top military commander". CBC News. 5 March 2026. Retrieved 6 March 2026. Conservative foreign affairs critic Michael Chong accused Carney of contradicting himself and holding an utterly incoherent position on Iran over the past few days.
  35. "Poilievre calls out PM Carney for his absence during debate on Iran war". CTV News. 9 March 2026. Retrieved 12 March 2026.
  36. "Canada's Stance on the War in Iran – March 10, 2026". CPAC. 10 March 2026. Retrieved 11 March 2026.
  37. "Former foreign affairs minister criticizes Canada's 'confusing' response to Iran war". CTV News. 9 March 2026. Retrieved 11 March 2026.
  38. "Canada could be called on to help defend Gulf states, says top military commander". CBC News. 5 March 2026. Retrieved 6 March 2026. Questions about Canada's potential involvement have been percolating since Carney addressed a question during a news conference in Australia Thursday local time.
  39. "Did Canadian exchange officers participate in U.S. Iran strike planning? DND says no, but questions linger". CBC News. 1 March 2026. Archived from the original on 1 March 2026. Retrieved 2 March 2026. Unless the Canadian government said, 'No, you cannot be directly engaged in this conflict,' then … typically, when we attach officers to another military and they go to war and the prime minister endorses this attack, then it's quite likely that they're actively engaged in the targeting process," Thompson told CBC News. He said Canada has members of three branches of the military — army, navy and air force —attached to CENTCOM and "we specifically have staff officers inside what's known as the Combined Aerospace Operations Center ... so, they are going to be directly involved in targeting.
  40. "The little we know about Canadian troops stationed in the Middle East". City News Halifax. 5 March 2026. Retrieved 6 March 2026. In a Toronto Star article citing Thompson's comments, former foreign affairs minister Lloyd Axworthy said Canadians deserve clarity. "You cannot embed Canadian officers in U.S. war-fighting headquarters, plug Canadian intelligence into targeting processes, then wash your hands when missiles fly," Axworthy wrote. "If Canadian personnel helped plan, analyze or enable an operation, Canada is implicated — whether or not a Canadian finger was on the trigger."
  41. "Did Canadian exchange officers participate in U.S. Iran strike planning? DND says no, but questions linger". CBC News. 1 March 2026. Archived from the original on 1 March 2026. Retrieved 3 March 2026. The Department of National Defence website shows that as many as 18 military personnel with the Canadian Armed Forces (CAF) are attached to Operation Foundation, working at the U.S. Fifth Fleet headquarters in Bahrain and at the Combined Aerospace Operations Centre (CAOC) at Al Udeid airbase in Qatar.
  42. "Canadian troops in Middle East 'are all fine' amid Iran war, McGuinty says". Global News. 3 March 2026. Archived from the original on 3 March 2026. Retrieved 6 March 2026.
  43. Rios, Michael (3 March 2026). "Iranian missile hits largest US military base in Middle East, Qatar says". CNN. Retrieved 4 March 2026.
  44. "Canadian military instillation in Kuwait hit by Iranian missiles". Western Standard. 12 March 2026. Retrieved 12 March 2026.
  45. "Canadian government grilled for secrecy over Kuwait airbase attack". Iran International . 13 March 2026. Retrieved 15 March 2026.
干扰字符镜像 镜像站群霸屏 网站备份克隆 镜像站群霸屏 关键词转码站群