| Year | Class | Winner | Ass'n | Runner Up | Ass'n | W Score | RU Score | OTs |
|---|
| 1979 | AAA | St. Anthony's (South Huntington) | CHSAA | Mount Vernon | NYSPHSAA | 36 | 34 | |
| AA | Nazareth (Brooklyn) | Norman Thomas (NYC) | PSAL | 76 | 69 | |
| A | St. Agnes (NYC) | Cuba | NYSPHSAA | 106 | 62 | |
| B | Bishop Neumann (Williamsville) | Bridgehampton | 68 | 65 | 1 |
| 1980 | A | Holy Trinity (Hicksville) | Ward Melville (East Setauket) | 53 | 48 | |
| B | Tolentine (Bronx) | Bellport | 74 | 67 | |
| C | St. Dominic (Oyster Bay) | Lyons | 61 | 45 | |
| D | Bridgehampton | NYSPHSAA | Our Saviour Lutheran (Bronx) | NYSAISAA | 77 | 73 | |
| 1981 | A | Xaverian (Brooklyn) | CHSAA | Mount Vernon | NYSPHSAA | 67 | 66 | |
| B | Malverne | NYSPHSAA | Tolentine (Bronx) | CHSAA | 55 | 54 | |
| C | Long Island Lutheran (Brookville) | NYSAISAA | Wyandanch | NYSPHSAA | 60 | 59 | |
| D | Our Saviour Lutheran (Bronx) | Tuckahoe | 84 | 54 | |
| 1982 | A | Benjamin Franklin (NYC) | PSAL | Spring Valley | 56 | 55 | |
| B | Nottingham (Syracuse) | NYSPHSAA | St. Agnes (NYC) | CHSAA | 74 | 69 | |
| C | Long Island Lutheran (Brookville) | NYSAISAA | Wyandanch | NYSPHSAA | 68 | 43 | |
| D | New York Mills | NYSPHSAA | McBurney (NYC) | NYSAISAA | 64 | 63 | |
| 1983 | A | North Babylon | Springfield Gardens | PSAL | 87 | 73 | |
| B | Bishop Loughlin (Brooklyn) | CHSAA | Bennett (Buffalo) | NYSPHSAA | 96 | 68 | |
| C | Charlotte (Rochester) | NYSPHSAA | Wyandanch | 88 | 57 | |
| D | Our Saviour Lutheran (Bronx) | NYSAISAA | Brookfield | 85 | 54 | |
| 1984 | A | Harry S. Truman (Bronx) | PSAL | Sweet Home (Amherst) | 67 | 65 | 1 |
| B | Bennett (Buffalo) | NYSPHSAA | Holy Cross (Flushing) | CHSAA | 65 | 57 | |
| C | Charlotte (Rochester) | Dalton (NYC) | NYSAISAA | 47 | 46 | |
| 1985 | A | All Hallows (Bronx) | CHSAA | Binghamton | NYSPHSAA | 66 | 63 | 1 |
| B | Samuel Gompers (Bronx) | PSAL | Westbury (Old Westbury) | 72 | 54 | |
| C | Nichols (Buffalo) | NYSAISAA | Wheatley (Old Westbury) | 74 | 55 | |
| 1986 | A | Binghamton | NYSPHSAA | Abraham Lincoln (Brooklyn) | PSAL | 79 | 61 | |
| B | Xaverian (Brooklyn) | CHSAA | Manhasset | NYSPHSAA | 71 | 70 | |
| C | Nichols (Buffalo) | NYSAISAA | Wilson Magnet (Rochester) | 63 | 59 | |
| 1987 | A | Our Saviour Lutheran (Bronx) | Archbishop Molloy (Briarwood) | CHSAA | 71 | 61 | |
| B | Nottingham (Syracuse) | NYSPHSAA | Christ the King (Middle Village) | 72 | 70 | |
| C | Trott Vocational (Niagara Falls) | Regis (NYC) | 57 | 86 | |
| 1988 | A | Tolentine (Bronx) | CHSAA | Our Saviour Lutheran (Bronx) | NYSAISAA | 95 | 69 | |
| B | La Salle (Niagara Falls) | NYSPHSAA | Samuel Gompers (Bronx) | PSAL | 80 | 67 | |
| C | Turner-Carroll (Buffalo) | CHSAA | Stillwater | NYSPHSAA | 86 | 87 | |
| 1989 | A | Christ the King (Middle Village) | Adlai Stevenson (Bronx) | PSAL | 80 | 57 | |
| B | Nazareth (Brooklyn) | East Hampton | NYSPHSAA | 54 | 36 | |
| C | Lyons | NYSPHSAA | Nichols (Buffalo) | NYSAISAA | 77 | 70 | |
| 1990 | A | William Grady (Brooklyn) | PSAL | Hempstead | NYSPHSAA | 78 | 67 | |
| B | Jamesville-DeWitt | NYSPHSAA | James Monroe (Bronx) | PSAL | 72 | 57 | |
| C | Nichols (Buffalo) | NYSAISAA | Rensselaer | NYSPHSAA | 67 | 89 | |
| 1991 | A | Mount Vernon | NYSPHSAA | Abraham Lincoln (Brooklyn) | PSAL | 59 | 49 | |
| B | Nottingham (Syracuse) | Julia Richman (NYC) | 65 | 49 | |
| C | Watervliet | Turner-Carroll (Buffalo) | CHSAA | 82 | 63 | |
| 1992 | A | Bishop Loughlin (Brooklyn) | CHSAA | Greece Athena (Rochester) | NYSPHSAA | 68 | 57 | |
| B | George Fowler (Syracuse) | NYSPHSAA | St. Joseph's Collegiate Institute (Tonawanda) | CHSAA | 60 | 59 | |
| C | Mynderse Academy (Seneca Falls) | Regis (NYC) | 84 | 91 | |
| 1993 | A | St. Raymond (Bronx) | CHSAA | Walton (Bronx) | PSAL | 96 | 81 | |
| B | Norwich | NYSPHSAA | St. Joseph's Collegiate Institute (Tonawanda) | CHSAA | 75 | 69 | |
| C | Regis (NYC) | CHSAA | Whitney Point | NYSPHSAA | 43 | 41 | |
| 1994 | A | Rice (NYC) | White Plains | 82 | 54 | |
| B | Long Island Lutheran (Brookville) | NYSAISAA | Norwich | 71 | 53 | |
| C | Cardinal O'Hara (Tonawanda) | CHSAA | Bishop Ludden (Syracuse) | 77 | 72 | |
| 1995 | A | Abraham Lincoln (Brooklyn) | PSAL | Christ the King (Middle Village) | CHSAA | 55 | 52 | |
| B | Mount St. Michael (Bronx) | CHSAA | Francis Lewis (Fresh Meadows) | PSAL | 64 | 39 | |
| C | Nichols (Buffalo) | NYSAISAA | Sacred Heart (Yonkers) | CHSAA | 74 | 44 | |
| 1996 | A | Rice (NYC) | CHSAA | La Salle (Niagara Falls) | NYSPHSAA | 84 | 65 | |
| B | Peekskill | NYSPHSAA | St. Dominic (Oyster Bay) | CHSAA | 62 | 57 | 1 |
| C | Buffalo Traditional | Collegiate (NYC) | NYSAISAA | 92 | 71 | |
| 1997 | A | Long Island Lutheran (Brookville) | NYSAISAA | Paul Robeson (Brooklyn) | PSAL | 53 | 50 | |
| B | St. Dominic (Oyster Bay) | CHSAA | Westhill (Geddes) | NYSPHSAA | 53 | 50 | |
| C | Salesian (New Rochelle) | Christian Brothers Academy (DeWitt) | 65 | 62 | |
| 1998 | A | Rice (NYC) | Long Island Lutheran (Brookville) | NYSAISAA | 80 | 65 | |
| B | Westhampton Beach | NYSPHSAA | Wadleigh (NYC) | PSAL | 62 | 51 | |
| C | Turner-Carroll (Buffalo) | CHSAA | Sidney | NYSPHSAA | 68 | 55 | |
| 1999 | A | Rice (NYC) | Cardozo (Bayside) | PSAL | 93 | 65 | |
| B | Turner-Carroll (Buffalo) | Southampton | NYSPHSAA | 66 | 63 | |
| C | Lawrence Woodmere Academy | NYSAISAA | Salesian (New Rochelle) | CHSAA | 63 | 43 | |
| 2000 | A | Mount Vernon | NYSPHSAA | John F. Kennedy (Bronx) | PSAL | 60 | 58 | |
| B | St. Mary's (Manhasset) | CHSAA | Amityville | NYSPHSAA | 55 | 49 | |
| C | Poly Prep (Brooklyn) | NYSAISAA | Buffalo Traditional | 51 | 50 | |
| 2001 | A | St. Raymond (Bronx) | CHSAA | Schenectady | 62 | 49 | |
| B | Amityville Memorial | NYSPHSAA | Benjamin Banneker Academy (Brooklyn) | PSAL | 91 | 73 | |
| C | Buffalo Traditional | Canisius (Buffalo) | CHSAA | 65 | 53 | |
| 2002 | A | Rice (NYC) | CHSAA | Henninger (Syracuse) | NYSPHSAA | 61 | 53 | |
| B | St. Mary's (Manhasset) | Amityville Memorial | 65 | 61 | 1 |
| C | Lawrence Woodmere Academy | NYSAISAA | Blind Brook (Rye Brook) | 44 | 39 | |
| 2003 | A | Abraham Lincoln (Brooklyn) | PSAL | Christ the King (Middle Village) | CHSAA | 75 | 73 | 1 |
| B | Amityville Memorial | NYSPHSAA | Chaminade (Mineola) | 65 | 57 | |
| C | Brooklyn Friends | NYSAISAA | City Honors (Buffalo) | NYSPHSAA | 69 | 68 | 1 |
| 2004 | AA | Mount Vernon | NYSPHSAA | Abraham Lincoln (Brooklyn) | PSAL | 66 | 52 | |
| A | Jamesville-DeWitt | St. Joseph's Collegiate Institute (Tonawanda) | CHSAA | 77 | 73 | 1 |
| B | John F. Kennedy Catholic (Somers) | McKinley Arts (Brooklyn) | PSAL | 81 | 61 | |
| D | Blind Brook (Rye Brook) | Tully (Tully, NY) | 52 | 43 | |
| 2005 | AA | Niagara Falls | Xaverian (Brooklyn) | CHSAA | 68 | 65 | |
| A | St. Anthony's (South Huntington) | CHSAA | Peekskill | NYSPHSAA | 61 | 50 | |
| B | Regis (NYC) | Palmyra-Macedon | 64 | 48 | |
| 2006 | AA | Mount Vernon | NYSPHSAA | Abraham Lincoln (Brooklyn) | PSAL | 62 | 60 | |
| A | Peekskill | Lawrence Woodmere Academy | NYSAISAA | 81 | 75 | |
| B | Global Studies (Brooklyn) | PSAL | Blessed Sacrament (New Rochelle) | CHSAA | 78 | 73 | |
| 2007 | AA | Abraham Lincoln (Brooklyn) | Rice (NYC) | 68 | 62 | |
| A | Peekskill | NYSPHSAA | Cardinal Hayes (Bronx) | 44 | 42 | |
| B | Malverne | Blessed Sacrament (New Rochelle) | 90 | 81 | |
| 2008 | AA | Abraham Lincoln (Brooklyn) | PSAL | Holy Cross (Flushing) | 86 | 67 | |
| A | Jamesville-DeWitt | NYSPHSAA | Long Island Lutheran (Brookville) | NYSAISAA | 70 | 66 | |
| B | Collegiate (NYC) | NYSAISAA | St. Agnes (NYC) | CHSAA | 57 | 44 | |
| 2009 | AA | Rice (NYC) | CHSAA | Newburgh Free Academy | NYSPHSAA | 70 | 68 | 1 |
| A | Long Island Lutheran (Brookville) | NYSAISAA | Jamesville-DeWitt | 68 | 51 | |
| B | Collegiate (NYC) | Bishop Kearney (Irondequoit) | 57 | 55 | |
| 2010 | AA | Christ the King (Middle Village) | CHSAA | Boys and Girls (Brooklyn) | PSAL | 52 | 49 | |
| A | Nichols (Buffalo) | Jamesville-DeWitt | NYSPHSAA | 65 | 43 | |
| B | Collegiate (NYC) | NYSAISAA | Queens H.S. of Teaching | PSAL | 61 | 41 | |
| 2011 | AA | Mount Vernon | NYSPHSAA | Christ the King (Middle Village) | CHSAA | 84 | 78 | 1 |
| A | Long Island Lutheran (Brookville) | NYSAISAA | St. Mary's (Manhasset) | 78 | 51 | |
| B | Collegiate (NYC) | Salesian (New Rochelle) | 48 | 46 | |
| 2012 | AA | Boys and Girls (Brooklyn) | PSAL | Mount Vernon | NYSPHSAA | 66 | 60 | |
| A | Long Island Lutheran (Brookville) | NYSAISAA | Harborfields (Greenlawn) | 62 | 61 | |
| B | Collegiate (NYC) | Bishop Ludden (Syracuse) | 62 | 52 | |
| 2013 | AA | Christ the King (Middle Village) | CHSAA | Long Island Lutheran (Brookville) | NYSAISAA | 73 | 64 | |
| A | Albany Academy | NYSAISAA | John Adams (Ozone Park) | PSAL | 50 | 34 | |
| B | Monsignor Scanlan (Bronx) | CHSAA | Fannie Lou Hamer Freedom (Bronx) | 52 | 50 | |
| 2014 | AA | Christ the King (Middle Village) | Long Island Lutheran (Brookville) | NYSAISAA | 58 | 52 | |
| A | Scotia-Glenville | NYSPHSAA | Holy Trinity (Hicksville) | CHSAA | 68 | 52 | |
| B | Westhill (Geddes) | Regis (NYC) | 65 | 46 | |
| 2015 | AA | Wings Academy (Bronx) | PSAL | Christ the King (Middle Village) | 79 | 73 | |
| A | Canisius (Buffalo) | CHSAA | Albany Academy | NYSAISAA | 48 | 44 | |
| B | Park (Amherst) | Maspeth | PSAL | 70 | 51 | |
| 2016 | AA | Thomas Jefferson Campus (Brooklyn) | PSAL | Aquinas Institute (Rochester) | NYSPHSAA | 72 | 65 | |
| A | Albany Academy | NYSAISAA | Elmont Memorial | 67 | 51 | |
| B | Collegiate (NYC) | Olean | 49 | 45 | |
| 2017 | AA | Abraham Lincoln (Brooklyn) | PSAL | Long Island Lutheran (Brookville) | NYSAISAA | 80 | 63 | |
| A | Albany Academy | NYSAISAA | Walton Campus (Bronx) | NYSPHSAA | 76 | 46 | |
| B | La Salle Academy (NYC) | CHSAA | Westhill (Geddes) | 80 | 67 | |
| 2018 | AA | Archbishop Stepinac (White Plains) | South Shore Campus (Brooklyn) | PSAL | 88 | 76 | |
| A | Park (Amherst) | Albany Academy | NYSAISAA | 59 | 57 | |
| B | Fannie Lou Hamer Freedom (Bronx) | PSAL | Mekeel Christian Academy (Scotia) | NYSPHSAA | 74 | 62 | |
| 2019 | AA | Long Island Lutheran (Brookville) | NYSAISAA | Christ the King (Middle Village) | CHSAA | 51 | 31 | |
| A | Albany Academy | Frederick Douglass Academy (NYC) | PSAL | 75 | 49 | |
| B | Glens Falls | Cardinal O'Hara (Tonawanda) | CHSAA | 88 | 79 | |
| 2020 | Cancelled, due to coronavirus pandemic [1] |