英文互译镜像站

1892 United States presidential election in Michigan

Last updated

1892 United States presidential election in Michigan
Flag of Michigan (1865-1911, obverse).svg
  1888
November 8, 1892
1896  
  Benjamin Harrison 1896.jpg StephenGroverCleveland.jpg
Nominee Benjamin Harrison Grover Cleveland
Party Republican Democratic
Home state Indiana New York
Running mate Whitelaw Reid Adlai Stevenson I
Electoral vote95
Popular vote222,708202,296
Percentage47.72%43.34%

Michigan Presidential Election Results 1892.svg
1892 United States presidential election in Michigan by Congressional District.svg

President before election

Benjamin Harrison
Republican

Elected President

Grover Cleveland
Democratic

The 1892 United States presidential election in Michigan took place on November 8, 1892. All contemporary 44 states were part of the 1892 United States presidential election. Voters chose 14 electors to the Electoral College, which selected the president and vice president.

Contents

Uniquely, this remains the only presidential election where Michigan used the congressional district method of distributing electoral votes rather than the traditional election of each elector by the state as a whole. The switch was made by the newly elected 1890 Democratic legislature, which had gained control of the state for the first time since before the Civil War. [1] [2] The change was an attempt at boosting Democratic candidate Grover Cleveland's chances of winning a second, nonconsecutive term, who had run in the previous election and won the popular vote, but lost in the electoral college. Controversial among Republicans, the party fought all the way to the Supreme Court in efforts to prevent it, the Court ruling in McPherson v. Blacker that allocating electoral votes this way was constitutional. [3] The split ultimately had no effect in Cleveland's victory, and the system was quickly repealed when Republicans regained control after the election. This is the only instance of Michigan splitting its electoral votes among multiple candidates. A law later passed in 1954 that prohibits faithless electors prevents a similar occurrence, barring a return to the district method. [4] [5]

Michigan was won by the Republican nominees: incumbent President Benjamin Harrison of Indiana and his running mate Whitelaw Reid of New York. The pair received nine of the state's electoral votes, while the Democratic ticket earned five.

Cleveland became the first Democratic presidential candidate since Franklin Pierce in 1852 to get electoral votes from Michigan, although the state wouldn't send a full slate of Democratic electors to the Electoral College until Franklin Delano Roosevelt won it in 1932.

Statewide results

Michigan was divided into two at large districts that chose one elector each. Cleveland won the eastern district and Harrison won the western district. Both districts also separately elected alternate presidential electors.

At Large districts

1892 United States presidential election in Michigan - Eastern District [6] [7]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Democratic George H. Durand 108,956 46.90%
Republican William McPherson Jr.107,41846.24%
Prohibition Henry A. Reynolds8,6333.72%
Populist William R. Alger7,1693.09%
Independent Scattering61 [a] 0.03%
Independent Blank730.03%
Total votes232,310 100.00%
Plurality1,5380.66%
1892 United States presidential election in Michigan - Western District [6] [7]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican Jay A. Hubbell 115,290 49.18%
Democratic John Power93,34039.82%
Populist Oscar F. Bean12,7625.44%
Prohibition Samuel Dickie12,2245.21%
Independent Scattering791 [b] 0.34%
Total votes234,407 100.00%
Plurality21,9509.36%

The statewide results for the presidential candidates themselves are the combined results for their respective electors in the eastern and western districts. Note, however, that the full statewide results had no effect on the outcome; all electors were chosen individually. Each voter chose only two of the state's 14 electors: one for their respective at large district and one for their respective congressional district (see below).

1892 United States presidential election in Michigan [6] [7]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican Benjamin Harrison (incumbent) 222,708 47.72%
Democratic Grover Cleveland 202,29643.34%
Prohibition John Bidwell 20,8574.47%
Populist James B. Weaver 19,9314.27%
Independent Scattering8520.18%
Independent Blank730.02%
Total votes466,717 100.00%
Plurality20,4124.37%

Results by county

County [6] [7] Benjamin Harrison
Republican
Grover Cleveland
Democratic
John Bidwell
Prohibition
James B. Weaver
Populist
MarginTotal votes cast
#%#%#%#%#%
Alcona 55657.32%38039.18%292.99%50.52%17618.14%970
Alger 16050.31%15649.06%20.63%00.00%41.26%318
Allegan 4,28350.96%3,20738.16%5446.47%3714.41%1,07612.80%8,405
Alpena 1,52649.11%1,53649.44%260.84%190.61%-10-0.32%3,107
Antrim 1,14052.17%81437.25%1647.51%673.07%32614.92%2,185
Arenac 32227.81%37332.21%262.25%43737.74%-64 [c] -5.53%1,158
Baraga 37536.76%63061.76%121.18%30.29%-255-25.00%1,020
Barry 2,85449.20%1,80031.03%2975.12%85014.65%1,05418.17%5,801
Bay 4,58742.96%5,71453.51%1871.75%1901.78%-1,127-10.55%10,678
Benzie 77452.47%49833.76%1016.85%1026.92%27618.71%1,475
Berrien 4,97948.55%4,71645.98%4264.15%1351.32%2632.56%10,256
Branch 3,27149.68%2,16132.82%4266.47%72611.03%1,11016.86%6,584
Calhoun 5,07748.10%4,15039.31%7106.73%6195.86%9278.78%10,556
Cass 2,73147.71%2,42442.35%1803.14%3896.80%3075.36%5,724
Charlevoix 1,10153.14%68833.20%1416.81%1426.85%41319.93%2,072
Cheboygan 1,09444.27%1,22449.53%742.99%793.20%-130-5.26%2,471
Chippewa 1,24752.33%1,08345.45%351.47%180.76%1646.88%2,383
Clare 71941.90%81147.26%1679.73%00.00%-92-5.36%1,716 [d]
Clinton 3,13348.42%2,75642.60%2583.99%3234.99%3775.83%6,470
Crawford 30048.62%30649.59%30.49%81.30%-6-0.97%617
Delta 1,76954.30%1,41243.34%401.23%371.14%35710.96%3,258
Dickinson 1,60651.05%1,25539.89%2558.11%300.95%35111.16%3,146
Eaton 3,78848.24%2,83736.13%4986.34%7309.30%95112.11%7,853
Emmet 1,01546.28%1,05948.29%1024.65%170.78%-44-2.01%2,193
Genesee 4,78550.14%3,71238.90%5906.18%4564.78%1,07311.24%9,543
Gladwin 53160.82%32537.23%131.49%40.46%20623.60%873
Gogebic 2,34457.25%1,61539.45%1162.83%190.46%72917.81%4,094
Grand Traverse 1,73454.70%92429.15%1855.84%32710.32%81025.55%3,170
Gratiot 3,03748.83%1,66126.70%2564.12%1,26620.35%1,37622.12%6,220
Hillsdale 4,11953.65%2,61334.03%4866.33%4605.99%1,50619.61%7,678
Houghton 3,31645.84%2,60736.04%5687.85%00.00%7099.80%7,234 [e]
Huron 1,69235.35%2,22246.42%1753.66%69814.58%-530-11.07%4,787
Ingham 4,34144.08%4,06141.23%4995.07%9489.63%2802.84%9,849
Ionia 4,28849.45%3,77943.58%3794.37%2252.59%5095.87%8,671
Iosco 1,39349.57%1,33647.54%582.06%230.82%572.03%2,810
Iron 91859.26%58737.90%00.00%150.97%33121.37%1,549 [f]
Isabella 1,85945.42%1,76243.05%1533.74%3197.79%972.37%4,093
Jackson 5,13045.02%5,00543.92%5715.01%6906.05%1251.10%11,396
Kalamazoo 4,96850.56%4,01840.90%4494.57%3903.97%9509.67%9,825
Kalkaska 71759.45%38932.26%604.98%403.32%32827.20%1,206
Kent 12,38846.31%11,53343.11%1,4115.27%1,4185.30%8553.20%26,750
Keweenaw 40065.36%20233.01%50.82%50.82%19832.35%612
Lake 64847.79%61044.99%634.65%352.58%382.80%1,356
Lapeer 3,12649.11%2,69842.39%3134.92%2283.58%4286.72%6,365
Leelanau 76953.63%49234.31%443.07%1299.00%27719.32%1,434
Lenawee 5,83346.86%5,59244.92%9107.31%1140.92%2411.94%12,449
Livingston 2,44743.76%2,38542.65%3656.53%3957.06%621.11%5,592
Luce 23455.45%16037.91%255.92%30.71%7417.54%422
Mackinac 47835.41%85563.33%90.67%80.59%-377-27.93%1,350
Macomb 2,78841.50%3,58453.35%2904.32%560.83%-796-11.85%6,718
Manistee 1,48135.42%2,31055.25%2315.52%1593.80%-829-19.83%4,181
Manitou 53.36%14496.64%00.00%00.00%-139-93.29%149
Marquette 3,87453.03%2,85039.01%5367.34%450.62%1,02414.02%7,305
Mason 1,42645.85%1,38344.47%2588.30%431.38%431.38%3,110
Mecosta 1,97051.76%1,48438.99%2205.78%1323.47%48612.77%3,806
Menominee 1,85348.43%1,80147.07%1343.50%380.99%521.36%3,826
Midland 1,06946.16%81535.19%1185.09%31413.56%25410.97%2,316
Missaukee 66548.61%62245.47%614.46%201.46%433.14%1,368
Monroe 2,91441.50%3,76953.68%2243.19%1141.62%-855-12.18%7,021
Montcalm 3,62353.31%2,20532.45%2653.90%70310.34%1,41820.87%6,796
Montmorency 24647.67%25549.42%101.94%50.97%-9-1.74%516
Muskegon 3,83049.76%3,30142.89%3224.18%2443.17%5296.87%7,697
Newaygo 2,10651.02%1,53137.09%2866.93%2054.97%57513.93%4,128
Oakland 4,76344.98%4,92546.51%7286.87%1741.64%-162-1.53%10,590
Oceana 1,63547.38%1,41641.03%3129.04%882.55%2196.35%3,451
Ogemaw 59450.64%51443.82%262.22%393.32%806.82%1,173
Ontonagon 67838.68%1,04159.38%191.08%150.86%-363-20.71%1,753
Osceola 1,60151.13%1,09234.88%3109.90%1284.09%50916.26%3,131
Oscoda 27359.09%18038.96%51.08%40.87%9320.13%462
Otsego 52547.60%53148.14%322.90%151.36%-6-0.54%1,103
Ottawa 3,64350.82%2,99641.79%1802.51%3504.88%6479.02%7,169
Presque Isle 29034.77%47156.47%70.84%50.60%-181-21.70%834 [g]
Roscommon 23944.26%28652.96%91.67%61.11%-47-8.70%540
Saginaw 6,73744.37%7,60150.07%2541.67%5903.89%-864-5.69%15,182
Sanilac 2,49454.34%1,73037.69%2886.27%781.70%76416.64%4,590
Schoolcraft 57041.79%65047.65%1017.40%433.15%-80-5.87%1,364
Shiawassee 3,61947.79%2,99439.54%6778.94%283 [h] [8] 3.74%6258.25%7,573
St. Clair 5,37148.82%5,24847.70%2282.07%810.74%1231.12%11,001 [i]
St. Joseph 2,82443.93%2,44137.97%1852.88%97815.21%3835.96%6,428
Tuscola 3,20149.42%2,66741.18%3976.13%2123.27%5348.24%6,477
Van Buren 3,78854.05%2,18231.14%4035.75%6359.06%1,60622.92%7,008
Washtenaw 4,36241.99%5,50853.02%4484.31%700.67%-1,146-11.03%10,388
Wayne 26,36147.81%27,58050.02%7021.27%4950.90%-1,219-2.21%55,138
Wexford 1,38849.91%1,15641.57%1856.65%521.87%2328.34%2,781
Totals222,70847.72%202,296 [j] 43.34%20,8574.47%19,9314.27%20,4124.37%466,717

Counties that flipped from Democratic to Republican

Counties that flipped from Republican to Democratic

District results

The remaining 12 electors were chosen by congressional district. Michigan gained one seat in the United States House of Representatives as a result of the 1890 United States Census and the state legislature redistricted prior to the 1892 elections. Each of the state's 12 congressional districts voted for a single presidential elector. Harrison won 8 of the 12 congressional districts. As with the at large districts, a full slate of alternate electors were also on the ballot.

Summary

District [6] [7] Benjamin Harrison
Republican
Grover Cleveland
Democratic
John Bidwell
Prohibition
James B. Weaver
Populist
MarginTotal votes cast
#%#%#%#%#%
1st district 18,33247.06%19,99051.32%3400.87%2910.75%-1,658-4.26%38,953
2nd district 20,94744.71%22,42747.87%2,4015.13%1,0722.29%-1,480-3.16%46,847
3rd district 21,23349.97%15,75637.08%2,5626.03%2,9386.91%5,47712.89%42,489
4th district 21,40249.19%20,08446.16%2,0244.65%00.00%1,3183.03%43,510
5th district 20,18747.72%18,17342.96%1,9674.65%1,9804.68%2,0144.76%42,307
6th district 21,32447.10%19,59043.27%2,2865.05%2,0704.57%1,7343.83%45,270
7th district 15,72345.05%15,98445.80%1,2833.68%1,8425.28%-261-0.75%34,902 [k]
8th district 16,67247.27%15,29843.37%1,2183.45%1,1493.26%1,3743.90%35,271 [l]
9th district 14,03647.25%12,85343.27%1,7545.90%1,0623.58%1,1833.98%29,705
10th district 14,37045.89%14,97247.82%7412.37%1,1673.73%-602-1.92%31,311 [g]
11th district 18,37950.75%12,73435.16%1,9615.41%3,1438.68%5,64515.59%36,217
12th district 19,81150.06%16,88842.68%1,8514.68%1,0232.59%2,9237.39%39,573
Totals222,41647.69%204,74943.90%20,3884.37%17,7373.80%17,6673.79%466,355

District 1

The 1st district was located entirely in Wayne County, covering the 1st through 11th and 13th and 15th wards of the city of Detroit. This was Cleveland's strongest district.

1892 United States presidential election in Michigan - 1st district [6] [7]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Democratic Rufus W. Gillett 19,990 51.32%
Republican J. Henry Carstens18,33247.06%
Prohibition Leicester B. Dodge3400.87%
Populist Arthur B. Hartford2910.75%
Total votes38,953 100.00%
Majority1,6584.26%

District 2

The 2nd district consisted of Jackson County, Lenawee County, Monroe County, Washtenaw County, and part of Wayne County [m] .

1892 United States presidential election in Michigan - 2nd district [6] [7]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Democratic Edwin R. Smith 22,427 47.87%
Republican Charles E. Hiscock20,94744.71%
Prohibition Joseph B. Steere2,4015.13%
Populist Martin G. Loenneker1,0722.29%
Total votes46,847 100.00%
Plurality1,4803.16%

District 3

The 3rd district consisted of Branch County, Calhoun County, Eaton County, Hillsdale County, and Kalamazoo County. This was Bidwell's strongest district.

1892 United States presidential election in Michigan - 3rd district [6] [7]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican Otto Ihling 21,233 49.97%
Democratic James S. Upton15,75637.08%
Populist Henry I. Allen2,9386.91%
Prohibition John H. Ferguson2,5626.03%
Total votes42,489 100.00%
Plurality5,47712.89%

District 4

The 4th district consisted of Allegan County, Barry County, Berrien County, Cass County, St. Joseph County, and Van Buren County. The Populists nominated the Democratic district elector for their ticket; thus there no votes for Weaver in this district. [9]

1892 United States presidential election in Michigan - 4th district [6] [7]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican Philip T. Colgrove 21,402 49.19%
Democratic Edward Hutchins20,08446.16%
Prohibition Hamilton S. McMaster2,0244.65%
Total votes43,510 100.00%
Plurality1,3183.03%

District 5

The 5th district consisted of Ionia County, Kent County, and Ottawa County.

1892 United States presidential election in Michigan - 5th district [6] [7]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican Conrad G. Swenberg 20,187 47.72%
Democratic Thomas Hefferan18,17342.96%
Populist Nathan B. Hayes1,9804.68%
Prohibition William Frye1,9674.65%
Total votes42,307 100.00%
Plurality2,0144.76%

District 6

The 6th district consisted of Genesee County, Ingham County, Livingston County, Oakland County, and part of Wayne County [n] .

1892 United States presidential election in Michigan - 6th district [6] [7]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican Henry A. Haigh 21,324 47.10%
Democratic Orlando F. Barnes19,59043.27%
Prohibition Lucius H. Ives2,2865.05%
Populist George Northrop2,0704.57%
Total votes45,270 100.00%
Plurality1,7343.83%

District 7

The 7th district consisted of Huron County, Lapeer County, Macomb County, Sanilac County, St. Clair County, and part of Wayne County [o] . This was the closest of the district races, with Cleveland's elector winning by only 261 votes.

1892 United States presidential election in Michigan - 7th district [6] [7]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Democratic Frank W. Hubbard 15,984 45.80%
Republican James H. White15,72345.05%
Populist Jedediah Spalding1,8425.28%
Prohibition George W. Smith1,283 [p] 3.68%
Independent Blank700.20%
Total votes34,902 100.00%
Plurality2610.75%

District 8

The 8th district consisted of Clinton County, Saginaw County, Shiawassee County, and Tuscola County.

1892 United States presidential election in Michigan - 8th district [6] [7]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican Frank Slocum 16,672 47.27%
Democratic William A. Woodard15,29843.37%
Prohibition William A. Heartt1,2183.45%
Populist Philo P. Miner1,1495.28%
Independent James M. Goodell9342.65%
Total votes35,271 100.00%
Plurality1,3743.90%

District 9

The 9th district consisted of Benzie County, Lake County, Leelanau County, Manistee County, Manitou County, Mason County, Muskegon County, Newaygo County, Oceana County,and Wexford County.

1892 United States presidential election in Michigan - 9th district [6] [7]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican James S. Stearns 14,036 47.25%
Democratic Martin Waalkes12,85343.27%
Prohibition Oscar A. Rowland1,754 [q] 5.90%
Populist George R. Kinsman1,0623.58%
Total votes29,705 100.00%
Plurality1,1833.98%

District 10

The 10th district consisted of Alcona County, Alpena County, Arenac County, Bay County, Cheboygan County, Crawford County, Emmet County, Gladwin County, Iosco County, Midland County, Montmorency County, Ogemaw County, Oscoda County, Otsego County, and Presque Isle County. Cleveland and Harrison tied in Alpena County (Cleveland won Alpena County by 10 votes in the Eastern district) and Weaver won Arenac County (which he also did in the Eastern district).

1892 United States presidential election in Michigan - 10th district [6] [7]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Democratic Worthy L. Churchill 14,972 47.82%
Republican John Millen14,37045.89%
Populist Mendel J. Bailey1,1673.73%
Prohibition Clarence M. Church7412.37%
Independent Scattering61 [r] 0.19%
Total votes31,311 100.00%
Plurality6021.92%

District 11

The 11th district consisted of Antrim County, Charlevoix County, Clare County, Grand Traverse County, Gratiot County, Isabella County, Kalkaska County, Mecosta County, Missaukee County, Montcalm County, Osceola County, and Roscommon County. This was the strongest district for both Harrison and Weaver.

1892 United States presidential election in Michigan - 11th district [6] [7]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican Julius T. Hannah 18,379 50.75%
Democratic Lyman H. Pratt12,73435.16%
Populist Dewitt Vought3,1438.68%
Prohibition George W. Hall1,9615.41%
Total votes36,217 100.00%
Majority5,64515.59%

District 12

The 12th district consisted of Alger County, Baraga County, Chippewa County, Delta County, Dickinson County, Gogebic County, Houghton County, Iron County, Keweenaw County, Luce County, Mackinac County, Marquette County, Menominee County, Ontonagon County, and Schoolcraft County.

1892 United States presidential election in Michigan - 12th district [6] [7]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican John H. Comstock 19,811 50.06%
Democratic Frederick Braastad16,88842.68%
Prohibition Trowbridge Johns1,8514.68%
Populist Oscar M. Drake1,0232.59%
Total votes39,573 100.00%
Majority2,9237.39%

See also

Notes

  1. 54 votes for Archibald McDonell and 7 votes for Charles W. Deland (misspelling of Charles V. De Land). McDonell and De Land were the respective Republican and Democratic candidates for alternate elector in this district.
  2. 743 votes for William R. Alger, 29 votes for Trowbridge Johns, and 19 votes for Alsor F. Bean (apparent misspelling of Oscar F. Bean). Alger was the Populist nominee in the Eastern District and Johns was the Prohibition nominee in the 12th congressional district.
  3. In this county where Weaver ran ahead of Harrison and also Cleveland, margin given is Cleveland vote minus Weaver vote and percentage margin Cleveland percentage minus Weaver percentage.
  4. Includes 19 Scattering votes.
  5. Includes 743 Scattering votes.
  6. Includes 29 Scattering votes.
  7. 1 2 Includes 61 Scattering votes.
  8. The 1893-1894 Michigan Manual contains a typo for Alger in this county. The correct figure is 283, not 383.
  9. Includes 73 Blank votes.
  10. The county figures add up to 202,396; the error is in the eastern district with Durand's county results adding up to 109,056 rather than the stated 108,956.
  11. Includes 70 Blank votes.
  12. Includes 934 Scattering votes.
  13. Specifically, the townships of Brownstown, Canton, Ecorse, Huron, Monguagon, Plymouth, Romulus, Sumpter, Taylor, and Van Buren, and the city of Wyandotte.
  14. Specifically, the townships of Dearborn, Greenfield, Livonia, Nankin, Redford, and Springwells, and the 12th, 14th, and 16th wards of the city of Detroit.
  15. Specifically, the townships of Grosse Pointe and Hamtramck.
  16. Includes 506 votes for "George Washington Smith" that were counted separately.
  17. Includes 61 votes in Oceana County for "Oscar Rowland" that were listed separately.
  18. 54 for Milo Eastman and 7 for Rasmus Hanson, who were the Democratic and Republican alternate elector candidates, respectively.

References

  1. Egan, Paul. “Democrats Once Pulled the Same Electoral College Stunt.” Detroit Free Press, 21 Nov. 2014, http://www.freep.com/story/news/politics/2014/11/20/michigan-white-house-presidential-election-electoral-college/70028908/.
  2. Braun, Ken. “Ken Braun: It Didn't Matter Much When Democrats Decided to Divide Michigan's Electoral College Votes.” MLive.com, 19 Nov. 2014, http://www.mlive.com/lansing-news/index.ssf/2014/11/ken_braun_it_didnt_matter_much.html.
  3. McPherson v. Blacker , 146U.S.1 (1892).
  4. “Section 168.47 .” Michigan Legislature - Section 168.47, Legislative Council, State of Michigan, http://legislature.mi.gov/doc.aspx?mcl-168-47.
  5. “The Electoral College.” National Conference of State Legislators, 22 Aug. 2016, http://www.ncsl.org/research/elections-and-campaigns/the-electoral-college.aspx#faithless.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 Jochim, John W., ed. (1893). Official Directory and Legislative Manual of the State of Michigan for the Years 1893-1894. Lansing: Robert Smith & Co., State Printers and Binders. pp. 390–402. Retrieved January 19, 2026.
  7. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 "Official Canvass of the State of Michigan, 1892". The Lansing Journal. Lansing. February 3, 1893. pp. 3–6. Retrieved January 19, 2026.
  8. "The Official Vote". The Times. Owosso. November 25, 1892. p. 1. Retrieved January 19, 2026.
  9. "Sample Ballot". St. Joseph Saturday Herald. St. Joseph. November 5, 1892. p. 11. Retrieved January 19, 2026.
站群克隆软件 镜像站群 烟雨镜像程序 301镜像站群 递归网站下载